Steel Roofing vs. Shingles: Which Roofing Offers the Most Benefit?
The roof is one of the most important parts of your home and can easily bring about costly repairs if not installed properly. Keep in mind that the best roofing material will depend on the weather and climate of your area.
Steel roofing is expensive, but it is also one of the most durable materials you can have, as it is great for withstanding expansion and contraction. People choose metal roofs if they want longevity, durability, great resale value, energy efficiency, and resistance to the elements. Perhaps one of the biggest downsides to steel roofing, however, is its tendency to dent. That being said, steel roofs are definitely more eco-friendly. Oftentimes, the steel is recycled and can be recycled again after its time on your roof. It can also lower your energy bill because of its reflective qualities.
One of the most popular roofing materials out there are asphalt shingles. They are generally very affordable, involve low labor costs (they can even be installed yourself), extremely reliable, and maintain uniformity in the neighborhood. They come in many different colors and textures and can offer that traditional aesthetic most homeowners desire in a new home. Shingles might be more prone to damage compared to steel, especially over the long term. Damp conditions can cause algal and fungal growth. Ice can lead to cracks, and extreme temperature changes can knock off years. Most shingles, however, have a 15-30 year warranty. It depends on the environment, climate, and region.Installation, Repairs, and Costs
Asphalt shingles are easier to install and repair than steel roofs. It takes less time to install them, and they can sometimes go directly on top of the roof's existing layer. You can do this yourself, if you feel comfortable. Shingles are also much easier than steel roofing to repair because you can replace individual sheets. Doing it yourself can void the warranty, hiring a roofing contractor in Montgomery County, PA ensures it done correctly.
Steel roofs should be installed by a skilled and precise tradesman. In rare cases, the steel can be installed over an existing roof if the existing roof is in good condition. Repairs are a little more difficult because of how the panels join together. Steel roofing can be up to 9 times more expensive than shingles. Per 100 square feet, you can find steel roofing anywhere from $120-$900: $100-$200 for shingles. And that excludes installation.
The investment might very well be worth the cost, however, because of the money saved in energy bills, repairs later on down the road, and resale value. Both steel roofing and shingles have their pros and cons, so it comes down to personal preference and what will work best for your home and where your home is located.